Portsmouth’s Heywood Augustine Murder Trial Discontinued in Unforeseen Twist
In a surprising legal twist, Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Sherma Dalrymple has opted to discontinue the murder trial of Heywood Augustine, accused in the 2018 shooting death of Derek Peters in Portsmouth. The decision, communicated through a “notice of discontinuance,” comes a day after a jury had been empaneled to try the case.
Dalrymple, in court, articulated her decision, citing the absence of three crucial eyewitnesses and the broader interests of justice as motivating factors. Despite not being legally obligated to provide reasons for discontinuation, she highlighted the challenges in building a robust case without these key witnesses.
Justice Colin Williams, presiding over the matter, commended the DPP for what he deemed “the right decision” in legal terms, cautioning against being swayed by public opinions or outcry. “Don’t mind the comments,” he emphasized, “As DPP, you have to make the right decisions in law as a Minister of Justice.”
In an unexpected revelation, Dalrymple mentioned that the accused had raised a defense of self-defense, which could not be easily refuted. She acknowledged the accused’s legitimate claim of self-defense, coupled with the absence of key witnesses corroborating this defense.
The discontinuation reflects a commitment to legal rigor and fairness, as Dalrymple noted, “We are Ministers of justice, and it is not all about convictions.” This move, she suggested, contributes to addressing the backlog of cases, with a focus on expedited legal proceedings.
Dalrymple also took the opportunity to encourage the utilization of the extended gun amnesty, reinforcing the ongoing efforts to promote legal compliance regarding firearms and ammunition.
This article is copyright © 2023 DOM767
