Violent crime in Dominica has once again come to the forefront of national discourse, igniting debates over who is responsible and how to address the growing sense of insecurity among citizens. The question of who is to blame for this surge in crime is far from straightforward—it is a complex web of socio-economic conditions, governance decisions, law enforcement challenges, and external influences.
The Crime Surge: A National Concern
Dominica has historically been regarded as one of the safest islands in the Caribbean. Still, recent years have seen a disturbing increase in violent crime, particularly homicides, armed robberies, and drug-related violence. The most alarming aspect is the changing nature of crime, where once isolated incidents are now becoming more frequent and brutal.
Data suggests that 2023 and 2024 saw notable spikes in violent crime, including gang-related killings, domestic violence homicides, and unsolved murders that have left families without justice. The latest reports from law enforcement indicate that the number of homicides in 2024 was lower than in 2023, but this does not tell the whole story—many citizens believe that the fear of crime has increased, even if the statistics show a slight decline.
The Role of the Government: Failing to Address Root Causes?
One of the Roosevelt Skerrit administration’s main criticisms is its perceived failure to adequately address crime prevention beyond issuing reactive statements. The government has made repeated promises to increase law enforcement resources, deploy new crime-fighting technologies, and implement social programs, yet crime continues to plague the nation.
The lack of economic opportunities, especially for young people, has created a breeding ground for crime. Unemployment rates remain stubbornly high, and many youths see drug trafficking and gang activities as their only viable economic options.
Critics argue that the government’s focus on large-scale infrastructure projects, foreign investments, and the Citizenship by Investment (CBI) program has failed to trickle down benefits to the most vulnerable segments of society. The lack of equitable resource distribution has widened economic gaps, leading to resentment, desperation, and, ultimately, crime.
The Police and Justice System: Is Law Enforcement Failing?
Many Dominicans feel that law enforcement is ill-equipped, underfunded, and reactive rather than proactive. Several high-profile murders remain unsolved, and there is a perception that criminals can act with impunity.
One of the major issues plaguing the Dominica Police Force is limited investigative capacity. The forensic division lacks the necessary resources and training to process crime scenes effectively, leading to poor conviction rates and lengthy legal processes.
Moreover, there is a growing mistrust between citizens and the police, fueled by allegations of corruption, selective enforcement, and political interference in the justice system. Some claim that the police focus disproportionately on minor offenses while failing to dismantle larger criminal networks.
The judicial system also faces scrutiny, with critics arguing that sentencing is often inconsistent, and high-profile offenders sometimes evade justice due to legal loopholes or political connections.
The Drug Trade and External Influences
Dominica’s geographical location has long made it a transit point for drug traffickers, particularly for cocaine shipments moving between South America and North America. The influx of illegal firearms and narcotics has fueled gang activity, resulting in deadly turf wars that often spill into innocent communities.
Reports suggest that Dominica’s porous borders allow for the easy entry of weapons and illicit drugs, making it difficult for law enforcement to stem the tide of organized crime.
The Socio-Economic Divide: A Root Cause of Crime?
While government officials often attribute violent crime to external influences, many experts point to Dominica’s internal economic struggles as the primary driver of criminal behavior. The lack of stable employment, rising cost of living, and social inequality are pushing more individuals towards criminal activities to survive.
Additionally, mental health issues, domestic violence, and substance abuse are often overlooked contributors to violent crime. Many violent offenders have untreated psychological disorders or come from backgrounds of severe abuse and neglect, yet the island lacks adequate social services to intervene before these individuals turn to crime.
Who Is to Blame? A Shared Responsibility
Blaming any one entity for Dominica’s crime problem is oversimplified. The reality is that multiple institutions and factors share responsibility for the current situation.
- The Government: Has failed to implement long-term strategies to combat crime through economic empowerment, youth engagement, and judicial reform.
- The Police and Judicial System: Struggles with inefficiency, underfunding, and loss of public trust, which emboldens criminals.
- The Economy: High youth unemployment and social disparity create conditions that foster criminal behavior.
- External Criminal Networks: Drug cartels and illegal arms trade continue to fuel violent crime, despite national security efforts.
- Society at Large: The normalization of crime, lack of community intervention, and a culture of silence (where witnesses fear speaking out) have all contributed to the crisis.
The Way Forward: What Can Be Done?
If Dominica is serious about curbing violent crime, there needs to be a multi-faceted approach involving:
- Judicial Reform – Harsher penalties for violent offenders, improved legal processes, and better witness protection programs.
- Increased Law Enforcement Training – The police force must be modernized, with better investigative tools, forensic support, and intelligence operations.
- Economic Opportunities for Youth – Programs that provide vocational training, entrepreneurship incentives, and community mentorship could reduce youth involvement in crime.
- Stronger Border Security – Better maritime patrols and anti-smuggling operations to disrupt illegal arms and drug shipments.
- Community-Based Policing – Encouraging closer relationships between police and citizens to rebuild trust and encourage crime reporting.
Final Thoughts
Violent crime in Dominica is not an isolated problem, nor can it be blamed on one individual or institution. Instead, it is the result of systemic failures, economic hardship, and external criminal influences.
While law enforcement can increase security measures, the long-term solution lies in addressing the root causes of crime—poverty, inequality, and lack of opportunity.
If immediate and strategic action is not taken, the current crime crisis threatens to derail national progress, deter foreign investment, and undermine public confidence in the country’s leadership and institutions.
Dominicans must demand accountability, transparency, and concrete action—because safety is not a privilege, but a right for all citizens.
This article is copyright © 2025 DOM767
